Detail Level – Pt 1: Quantification

One of the biggest challenges in Revit is quantification. It is known that we only get out of the model, what we have put before as an object in the model. Wow, great theorem…
Now, maybe next hint can help you to understand Revit when it calculates the volumes of your structural elements.

FACT

For custom families, Revit uses the Medium Detail Level presentation to calculate it’s object volume.

This representation can be set in the Family Editor, by selecting the solid geometry and change it’s 
Visibility/Graphics Overrides parameter. Only the solid(s) which have at least the “Medium” option checked, will be taken into account in the objects volume calculation.

Medium Detail Level - Quantification 3Medium Detail Level - Quantification 4

PROBLEM

This informative parameter “Volume” is often used in schedules of Structural Columns, Structural Framing, … and medium detail level is often used for simplified representation of your model. This leads us to next “problematic” combination.

Example 1 – Concrete column with corbels

Imagine this column with corbels. When wanting to look at just structural volumes, you can switch off the corbels, by changing to Medium Detail level, but in that means that the object volume does only takes into account the core of the column.
(Volume = 0,3 x 0,3 x 3 = 0,27 m³)
Medium Detail Level - Quantification 1Example 2 – H-Wide Flange column
The default H-Wide Flange columns in the Revit content libraries by Autodesk works on the same principle. Medium detail level gives us simplified representation without filleted corners. But also this principle influences the objects volume.

Medium Detail Level - Quantification 2

SOLUTION

Instead of using object volumes in your “Schedules”, create “Material Takeoffs” and use the “Material: Volume” parameter. This will take the full solid geometry that is consumed by the material into account, which gives us exact values for quantification.

Medium Detail Level - Quantification 5

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s